Homemade Oreos with Peanut Butter
Published on March 01, 2013
Happy March! It’s a new month and it’s Friday so I think we need to celebrate with some cookies. How about Homemade Oreos with Peanut Butter? I’ve made homemade Oreos before and I’ve always enjoyed them, but adding peanut butter makes them irresistible. I am obsessed!
I’ve always loved peanut butter, but since Josh is allergic I think I love it even more. Is that weird? I think I double love it, for the both of us. Plus, I don’t eat it that often. I can’t be kissing my man with peanut butter breath, so I only eat it when he’s not around or if I can brush my teeth right away:) So peanut butter is more of a treat for me. When I do eat it, I savor every bite. Well, most of the time. I gobbled up these Homemade Oreos with Peanut Butter pretty quickly.
The chocolate cookies are rich, buttery, and crisp. The vanilla filling is creamy and sweet. The peanut butter balances out the sweetness in the best way. I used salted peanut butter because I love a little saltiness mixed in with my sweets.
Homemade Oreos with peanut butter oozing out the side are a VERY good thing. Trust me! Peanut butter maybe a simple ingredient, but it takes these Oreos to a whole new level. And since Josh is allergic to peanut butter, I made him a few regular Oreos. I just hid in the corner with my jar of peanut butter and slathered it on my cookies:)
Homemade Oreos with Peanut Butter are SO much better than store bought cookies. It’s amazing what a little peanut butter can do to a classic cookie. Thanks Tieghan for the recipe! You can find step-by-step photos and the recipe on Tasty Kitchen. Enjoy!
Those look fabulous and irresistible! Thousand times better than the bought version.
Cheers,
Rosa
That’s just so sad that Josh is allergic…gah, not good! But more for the rest of us. Beautiful, perfect looking cookies, Maria!
hmm- for some reason I can’t read this recipe once I click on your blog header? The picture looks delicious 🙂
Oh girl, these look TOO amazingly decadent!! 🙂 Must put these on my Make ASAP list 🙂
I saw this on Tasty Kitchen the other day and was drooling over it! I need these cookies in my life!! Have a wonderful weekend!!
I love this recipe! I’m that weirdo that watched The Parent Trap and started dipping my Oreos in peanut butter immediately. Such a wonderful combination and the greatest idea to hit this earth since sliced bread or wifi. But this would make it so much easier for me to enjoy the delicious treat!
oh my gosh! the only way Ill ever eat oreos is by dunking them in a lot of peanut butter! now I can totally skip that step! These look scrumptioius!!
Oh my! These look sooooo good! Your photography makes it look especially amazing! I have been wanting to make some home made oreos!
Oh my goodness! These were tempting me on TK the other day. Such a treat!
I want to hide in the corner with you. Save me a cookie?
Thanks fo the shout! Man who knew those cookies would be such a hit!! I need to make more! Thanks again!
Wow– these look like the best of all worlds…peanut butter and Oreo together. I know my kids would LOVE them as well!
I find the chocolate-peanut butter craving is one of the hardest to satisfy. These cookies look like they’ll do the trick! Clicking now…. Thanks!
If I could live on these, I’d try.
I adore these. Homemade Oreos are so great- but that ooey gooey melty peanut butter makes them even more delicious-sounding!
DEAR LORD! I would never be able to keep my hand out of that cookie jar!
This is equally the most ingenious and most dangerous thing ever. I LOVE IT.
No lying, I used to dip my regular Oreos into a peanut butter as a kid. Best way to eat Oreos ever. I am so going to be making these! Thanks Maria!
These are awesome, Maria!
These so beat any oreo that comes in a package!
These would be so dangerous! But they look so good!
That peanut butter oozing out? Sold.
Oh my Lord.
These look amazing!
oh my goodness- these look AMAZING!
Oh my gosh!! Completely drool worthy. You’re killing me here. I miss pb so much!!
Now these cookies are dazzlers!
homemade oreos?!? HELL YES
These look delicious! Both my daughters are allergic to peanut butter. Just curious how u made these without PB (what did u substitute for it in the oreo)? Thanks so much!
I just made Josh regular homemade Oreos, I didn’t spread the peanut butter on, only the cream filling.
LOVE these! Totally regretting my decision to give up peanut butter for Lent right now! Can’t wait until after Easter to make these 🙂
I would be so sad to be allergic to peanut butter!! Thankfully I’m not and shall be devouring these in the near future.
That looks like some ooey gooey peanut butter to me.
We have peanut allergies in our family too. We use School Safe Soy Butter. The only place I can find it is at Walmart. It taste just like peanut butter!
oh dear gosh – this looks AMAZING. just wow, Maria!!
These look soooo good!!
Wow!! This is so creative, and they look amazing!!!
Oh my lordy — the shots are simply amazing! I love how the filling drips 🙂
Totally over the top amazing Maria!
Heaven help me! Fabulous!!! xoxo
Oh, what a glorious idea this is to add peanut butter!!
I am dying to make Oreos at home, especially if they taste even better than the store bought cookies. And I know they would be good with peanut butter thanks to Lindsay Lohan in the Parent Trap 🙂
You had me at oozing peanut butter, these cookies look amazing, I can’t wait to make my own batch.
Love this twist of using peanut butter instead! I prefer pb over chocolate any day!
Best idea ever – these look just fabulous Maria!
I have to make homemade oreos soon, minus the pb for me too ; )
Such a great flavour combo and they look so good!
The pictures are AMAZING! These cookies look like they are flying out of my screen towards my mouth! The oozing cream is so tempting! Must go check the recipe!
Oh my world, I am totally drooling for a taste of these cookies!!! They look amaazing:)
so, i just went gluten and dairy free as well as no processed sugars (it’s for fertility purposes… i’m desperate). it won’t be permanent, but let me tell you… the second i take a break from this, this is what i will be eating! (drool)
These look delicious and like you I love peanut butter. I will be adding these to my list.
Love peanut butter! But the thing that’s so great about store-bought Oreo’s is that they’re actually vegan. So I’ll just go and spread some peanut butter on those 😀
Chocolate & peanut butter are my FAVORITE combination! Can’t wait to try these.
Oh my…the oozing peanut butter! These look like THE perfect oreos.
These look killer!!! Going on my must make this right now!
These look amazing! Never thought about adding Peanut Butter! For Peanut Allergies, I know folks using Almond Butter which is really quite available these days in health food stores! We can grind our own at WinCo stores which has an Almond Butter Grinder and a Peanut Butter Grinder with the salted, roasted nuts in them! I hope maybe Josh can enjoy Almond Butter.
Looks scrumptious!! Good after school snacks if Mom will actually save some.
Heaven help me! Fabulous 🙂