The 4 Best Brownie Pans of 2024
Published on April 02, 2024
Brownies are one of my all-time FAVORITE desserts! Nothing beats a fudgy, decadent brownie… except maybe one topped with more delicious treats or served with some ice cream — but I digress. Of course, you want to have one of the BEST brownie pans to perfectly bake these goodies, and I can help with that!
Pin this now to find it later
Pin ItI’ve been baking brownies for YEARS, and I’m happy to share my secrets, including what you need in your kitchen for the baking process to go smoothly. My list of the best brownie pans includes ones I’ve used and LOVE, along with picks that have rave reviews from shoppers. You can’t go wrong with any of them!
Check out my top picks for the best brownie pans below!
My Top Picks:
- What’s in My Kitchen: USA Pan Bakeware Rectangular Cake Pan – $25.97 at Amazon
- Best Splurge: Williams Sonoma Goldtouch Pro Nonstick Square Cake Pan – $34.95 at Williams Sonoma
- Best Budget: Wilton Performance Aluminum Square Cake and Brownie Pan – $10.72 at Amazon
- Best All Edge Brownie Pan: Baker’s Edge Brownie Pan – $54.99 at Amazon
Reviews of The Best Brownie Pans
1. What’s in My Kitchen: USA Pan Bakeware Rectangular Cake Pan
I prefer to make my brownies in a 9 by 13 pan, which may seem like a lot, but trust me you’ll be happy to have that many brownies. USA Pan makes amazing, sturdy bakeware that’s usually on the more affordable side, and this one is no exception! It’s a light-colored pan, which is always my preference for cookware because it doesn’t absorb as much heat as a dark pan. This usually means that it’ll have a nice, even bake.
Even though this isn’t dishwasher-safe, it cleans up easily because of its nonstick coating (plus, I recommend lining your brownie pan with parchment paper anyway so they’re easy to lift out). Use this rectangular pan to make my classic brownie recipe!
The Specs:
- Material: Aluminized steel
- Dimensions: 9 x 13 x 2.25 inches
- Weight: 1.9 pounds
- Nonstick: Yes
- Dishwasher safe: No
The Pros:
- Brownies release easily
- Sturdy design
- Distributes heat evenly
- Fits a lot of brownies
The Cons:
- Hand-wash only
What Others are Saying:
This has a 4.8-star rating from more than 4,300 reviews on Amazon, and Wirecutter dubbed it as the best brownie pan.
Buy the USA Pan Bakeware Rectangular Cake Pan:
2. Best Splurge: Williams Sonoma Goldtouch Pro Nonstick Square Cake Pan
I’m ALWAYS recommending products from Williams Sonoma’s Goldtouch Pro line because they look SO pretty and bake everything perfectly. This comes in 8- by 8-inch or 9- by 9-inch sizes, so the brownies will be a little thicker and require some extra oven time. Still, they’ll get an even bake, thanks to the light-colored steel. Plus, it doesn’t hurt that this pan is pretty enough to serve your goodies at a party.
The Specs:
- Material: Aluminized steel
- Dimensions: 8 x 8 x 2 inches, 9 x 9 x 2.25 inches
- Weight: 1.2 pounds, 1.6 pounds
- Nonstick: Yes
- Dishwasher safe: Yes
The Pros:
- Easy to clean
- Sleek design
- Distributes heat evenly
- Nonstick
The Cons:
- May take longer to bake
What Others are Saying:
Food & Wine named this the best overall brownie pan.
Buy the Williams Sonoma Goldtouch Pro Nonstick Square Cake Pan:
3. Best Budget: Wilton Performance Aluminum Square Cake and Brownie Pan
Wilton is always my go-to pick for budget-friendly baking supplies because it’s reliable and always gets great reviews. This aluminum pan, in particular, is durable while still being super lightweight, and it gives an even bake. It doesn’t have a nonstick coating, so if you don’t go with my parchment paper trick, make sure you add plenty of cooking spray to the pan so your brownies lift out easily. If you’re a first-time baker or just not looking to spend too much right now, this is a great option!
The Specs:
- Material: Aluminum
- Dimensions: 8 x 8 x 2 inches
- Weight: 0.4 pounds
- Nonstick: No
- Dishwasher safe: Yes
The Pros:
- Easy to clean
- Lightweight
- Affordable
The Cons:
- No nonstick coating
What Others are Saying:
This pan has a 4.4-star rating from more than 2,400 reviews on Amazon.
Buy the Wilton Performance Aluminum Square Cake and Brownie Pan:
4. Best All Edge Brownie Pan: Baker’s Edge Brownie Pan
I can never get enough of brownie edges — the crunchy, crispy portions are the BEST part! If you’re like me, you should totally grab this pan with center dividers that bake brownies with two crispy edges. I love that this pan has thick handles to make it even easier to carry, even with an oven mitt on, too. It offers some extra crunch, and there’s an included spatula to help get the brownies out! Just note that you might need to use a little less batter for these, so they don’t overflow.
The Specs:
- Material: Carbon steel
- Dimensions: 14.25 x 10 x 2.33 inches
- Weight: 1.8 pounds
- Nonstick: Yes
- Dishwasher safe: No
The Pros:
- Perfect for brownie edge lovers
- Distributes heat well
- Has handles for easier carrying
- Brownies lift out easily
The Cons:
- Hand-wash only
- Not a versatile option
- Expensive
Buy the Baker’s Edge Brownie Pan:
Other Brownie Pans to Consider
Gotham Steel Brownie Pan
If your dream brownie has four crispy edges, you’ll LOVE this pan. It has dividers to create 18 perfectly square brownies — that’s right, you don’t even need to cut them! The dividers slip in and out of the pan, so they’re easy to wash, too. It’s not as versatile as some of the options above, but still a nice one to consider. The Gotham Steel Brownie Pan is available at Amazon for $17.43.
Caraway Rectangle Pan
I’m a big fan of Caraway’s bakeware, so I had to give this pan a shoutout. It comes in so many pretty colors that you’ll want to serve brownies straight out of — and its slick ceramic coating makes it easy to lift them out. However, it costs a pretty penny, so it’s not for everyone. The Caraway Rectangle Pan is available at Amazon for $55.
Wilton Bite-Size Brownie Squares Silicone Mold
This brownie pan from Wilton makes the cutest individual brownie bites (24 of them!). It’s not all that different from a muffin pan, though, so while it’s a good one to consider if you like all-edge brownies, it may not be a necessary addition to your kitchen. The Wilton Bite-Size Brownie Squares Silicone Mold is available at Amazon for $5.99.
KitchenAid Nonstick Aluminized Steel Square Cake Pan
This is another nice square option that you could use for baking brownies or cakes. Its light metal means the brownies bake evenly, and its nonstick coating makes sure they release easily. Although I prefer a 9 by 13 pan for faster baking, this is a fine choice. The KitchenAid Nonstick Aluminized Steel Square Cake Pan is available at Amazon for $16.99.
Why You Can Trust Me
Hi, I’m Maria, the founder of Two Peas and Their Pod! I bake a TON, but brownies might secretly be my favorite sweet treat. They’re always a crowd-pleaser, and I’ve been perfecting my brownie recipes for years. Because of all that trial and error (and taste testing!), I know that a big part of getting it right is having a solid pan to cook them in.
To make sure I’m only recommending the best brownie pans, I leaned on my own experience trying out ones in my kitchen. I also searched through reviews on editorial sites and retailers like Amazon and Target to ensure they actually live up to their claims. Any one of these will help you whip up decadent brownies in no time!
Everything to Know Before Buying a Brownie Pan
What to Consider Before Buying a Brownie Pan
Before picking a brownie pan, here’s a few things I recommend thinking about first!
- Material: I recommend metal pans because they heat up and cool down quickly, so the baking process is a little easier but still quick. The brownies also rise higher and bake more evenly in metal pans. The trick is going with a light-colored metal because it’ll bake more evenly since it doesn’t absorb as much heat. More heat could mean the brownies get brown and crispy on the edges before actually cooking through the center.
- Size: You can find several different size brownie pans. My favorites are 9×13 inches because they make a large batch (about a dozen or two) in one swoop. They’ll also bake faster because it’s a thinner layer of batter than if you took the same recipe and squished it all into a smaller square pan. It’s all up to your preference, though!
- Style: If you’re a big fan of edge pieces, you might want to consider an all-edge brownie pan, like the Williams Sonoma, Gotham, or Wilton ones. Otherwise, you can stick to a typical pan that’s more versatile so you can use it for your other baking and cooking needs.
How Many Brownies Fit in a 9×13 Pan?
A 9×13-inch pan can make about 12 to 24 brownies, but it’s totally up to you! You can cut them into smaller or larger squares depending on how you want to serve them.
What Size is a Brownie Pan?
There are a variety of brownie pan sizes. I typically use a 9×13-inch pan, and even though that may seem big, the brownies definitely won’t go to waste in my house! But you can also use 7- by 11-inch or 8- by 12-inch pans — you’ll just need to bake them longer since the brownies will be thicker.
Can You Bake Brownies in a Glass Pan?
Yes, you can bake brownies in a glass pan, but again, I recommend metal pans. If you want to use a glass pan, bake the brownies for 5 minutes longer.
How Long Does it Take to Cook Brownies in a Muffin Pan?
I recommend using a mini muffin pan if you want to make bite-size brownies. And with that size pan, I recommend baking them at 350°F for 12 to 15 minutes. After that, continue to bake them until a toothpick comes out clean.
The Best Brownie Recipes
Whether you want to go all in on chocolatey goodness by adding Oreos or add a tropical flare with some coconut flakes, I’ve got a brownie recipe that’ll speak to your taste buds!
Prices were accurate at time of publication.
